Delhi High Court Issues Notice on Rule 4(4) and Automated Content Identification

A duty that once read as an endeavour now reads as an obligation. Since February 2026 the largest social media intermediaries in India have been required to deploy technical measures, including automated tools, to find certain material before anyone complains about it. On 19 November 2026 the Delhi High Court issued notice on a challenge to that duty, which puts automated content identification under the Information Technology (Intermediary Guidelines and Digital Media Ethics Code) Rules, 2021 before a Constitutional Court.
What the Sub-Rule Now Requires
Sub-rule (4) of rule 4 binds a significant social media intermediary, which is a social media intermediary having registered users in India above the threshold notified by the Central Government under clause (v) of sub-rule (1) of rule 2.
As the provision now stands, such an intermediary shall deploy appropriate technical measures, including automated tools or other suitable mechanisms, to proactively identify information in two categories. The first concerns depictions of certain grave sexual offences. The second is information exactly identical in content to information that has previously been removed, or access to which has previously been disabled, on the computer resource of that intermediary under clause (d) of sub-rule (1) of rule 3.
The sub-rule also requires a notice to be displayed to any user attempting to access such information, stating that the information has been identified by the intermediary under the categories referred to in the sub-rule. The notice duty is part of the obligation and not an optional courtesy.
The Words That Were Substituted
The Ministry's own consolidated printing of the Rules, updated as on 10 February 2026, carries a footnote to the opening words of the sub-rule. Before that date the provision required such an intermediary to endeavour to deploy technology-based measures, including automated tools or other mechanisms. Those words were substituted on 10 February 2026 by the words now in force.
That is a small textual change with a large legal consequence. An obligation to endeavour is discharged by making a genuine attempt. An obligation to deploy is discharged only by deployment. The second category makes the difference concrete, because identifying content exactly identical to content already removed is a task that in practice can only be done at scale by machine.
The Provisos Attached to the Duty
Three provisos qualify the sub-rule. The first requires that the measures taken be proportionate having regard to the interests of free speech and expression and the privacy of users on the computer resource of that intermediary, including interests protected through the appropriate use of technical measures.
The second requires the intermediary to implement mechanisms for appropriate human oversight of the measures deployed, including a periodic review of any automated tools deployed. The third sets out what that review must evaluate.
The provisos matter to how the sub-rule is read. The duty to deploy is not expressed as an unqualified command, and a reading of the obligation that ignores the first proviso reads only half the provision.
What Happened on 19 November 2026
A Division Bench of Acting Chief Justice Nitin Wasudeo Sambre and Justice Sanjay Sharma issued notice to the Union of India and to Meta. The respondents were given four weeks to file counter affidavits and the matter was listed for 18 January 2027.
Interim relief was not pressed at the hearing, so none was granted and none was refused. No finding was recorded on any question in the petition.
The petition was filed by Live Law Media Private Limited, which publishes legal news, and its director. It challenges sub-rule (4) of rule 4 as amended, so far as it requires the deployment of automated tools to identify information exactly identical to information already removed, and it also challenges two advisories issued by the Ministry of Electronics and Information Technology on 8 and 10 October 2026. The petition's case is that the sub-rule is beyond the Information Technology Act, 2000 and that the advisories have no statutory basis. The grounds taken include Articles 14, 19(1)(a), 19(1)(g) and 21 of the Constitution.
The Facts Behind the Petition
Three reports published on the publisher's verified account on one platform, each concerning proceedings in the Supreme Court, were restricted in India between 27 and 30 October 2026. Two of them were restricted within about fifteen minutes of being posted. One was restored the same day and two remain inaccessible. A further item was restricted on 18 November 2026, the day before the hearing.
Those facts are what the petition relies on to say that identical content matching operates on reports of court proceedings. Whether it did so in these instances, and on what legal basis, is exactly what the counter affidavits are expected to address.
What the Court Has Not Done
Nothing about the validity of the sub-rule has been decided. A notice is an invitation to answer, and the order carries no observation on the merits, no interim restraint and no direction to the intermediary to restore anything.
The provision therefore continues to operate exactly as before. Compliance obligations that fell due under it still fall due, and nothing in the order of 19 November 2026 suspends them or qualifies them.
Points to Watch
The textual change is the heart of it: endeavour to deploy became deploy, by a substitution dated 10 February 2026.
Two categories, not one: the second is information exactly identical to information already removed under clause (d) of sub-rule (1) of rule 3.
The notice to the user is part of the duty: a user attempting to access identified information is to be told that the intermediary identified it under the categories in the sub-rule.
The provisos qualify the obligation: proportionality, human oversight of the measures deployed, and a review of any automated tools.
Only a significant social media intermediary is bound: the threshold is notified by the Central Government under clause (v) of sub-rule (1) of rule 2.
Notice is not an interim order: none was sought at the hearing, so none was granted or refused, and the provision operates in full.
The date to diarise is 18 January 2027: counter affidavits were directed within four weeks.
Key Statutory Provisions
Sub-rule (4) of rule 4 of the Information Technology (Intermediary Guidelines and Digital Media Ethics Code) Rules, 2021: a significant social media intermediary shall deploy appropriate technical measures, including automated tools or other suitable mechanisms, to proactively identify information in the two categories described, and shall display a notice to any user attempting to access such information stating that it has been identified by the intermediary under those categories. The opening words were substituted on 10 February 2026 for the words endeavour to deploy technology-based measures, including automated tools or other mechanisms, as the issuing authority's own printing records in a footnote.
The provisos to that sub-rule: the measures shall be proportionate having regard to the interests of free speech and expression and privacy of users on the computer resource of that intermediary, including interests protected through the appropriate use of technical measures; and the intermediary shall implement mechanisms for appropriate human oversight of the measures deployed, including a periodic review of any automated tools deployed.
Clause (d) of sub-rule (1) of rule 3 and clause (v) of sub-rule (1) of rule 2: the second category is tied to information removed or disabled under the former, and the class of intermediary bound by the sub-rule is fixed by the threshold notified under the latter. Neither is set out further here.
Sources and References
The Rules as printed by the issuing authority, updated as on 10 February 2026
Independent printing of rule 4 carrying the pre-substitution text
Information Technology (Intermediary Guidelines and Digital Media Ethics Code) Rules, 2021
Disclaimer: This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Readers should consult a qualified legal professional for advice specific to their circumstances.


Comments