How to Exercise Independent Judgment on a Board Pack Written With AI

Updated: 3h
The papers arrive three days before the meeting, they are clearer than they used to be, and the summary at the front is excellent. Exercising independent judgment on material assembled with the help of a tool is not a new duty. It is an old one that becomes harder to discharge as the material gets better at sounding settled.
Step 1: Know Which Two Obligations Are Engaged
Sub-section (3) of section 166 of the Companies Act, 2013 provides that a director of a company shall exercise his duties with due and reasonable care, skill and diligence and shall exercise independent judgment.
Those are two obligations and they fail differently. Care and diligence is about what was checked before the decision. Independent judgment is about whose judgment the decision represents. Well drafted material can satisfy the first impression of both while supplying neither.
Step 2: Ask Who Prepared the Paper and On What
The useful question at the start of an item is not whether a tool was used. It is which parts of the paper are analysis by a person who can be asked about them, and which parts are a summary of something else.
A board that cannot get that answer for a significant item is being asked to decide on material nobody present will own, which is the condition under which independent judgment becomes impossible rather than merely difficult.
Step 3: Go to the Underlying Material for Anything Load Bearing
Where an item turns on a number, a contract term, a legal position or a forecast, the summary is not the thing. Ask for the source and read the part that carries the decision.
This is ordinary diligence and it was ordinary diligence before any of this. What has changed is that a summary now reads as though the checking has already been done, which makes the step easier to skip and no less necessary.
Step 4: Treat Confidence in the Text as Carrying No Information
Material produced this way is uniformly fluent. The parts that are well established and the parts that are contested read the same, and uncertainty that a person would have signalled often disappears in the drafting.
So the absence of hedging is not evidence that a point is settled. Where an item matters and the paper reads as though there is nothing to discuss, that is the moment to ask what the other view is.
Step 5: Record the Question, Not Only the Resolution
Minutes that record only the decision cannot show that judgment was exercised. Minutes that record what was asked, what was produced in answer and what the board made of it, can.
This is not a long addition. One line per contested item, naming the question and the answer, is the difference between a record that evidences diligence and a record that merely evidences attendance.
Step 6: Keep the Duty Personal
Sub-section (6) of section 166 provides that a director of a company shall not assign his office and any assignment so made shall be void. Whatever else that provision does, it marks the office as personal to the holder.
Read with sub-section (3), the practical reading is modest and clear. The duty to bring care, skill, diligence and independent judgment to a decision sits with each director, and it does not move to whoever or whatever prepared the paper.
Step 7: Deal With Conflicts the Tool Cannot See
Sub-section (4) provides that a director shall not involve in a situation in which he may have a direct or indirect interest that conflicts, or possibly may conflict, with the interest of the company.
A paper assembled from internal material will not surface a director's own position, and a recommendation that reads as neutral can still be one in which a director has an interest. The obligation to raise it is unaffected by how well the paper is written.
Step 8: Set the Expectation at Board Level, Once
Rather than policing individual papers, settle the standing expectation: that papers identify which parts are analysis and which are summary, that sources for load bearing material accompany the item, and that the person who can answer questions on an item attends for it.
Set once and minuted, that expectation does the work in every meeting afterwards and spares the board the awkwardness of raising it item by item.
Common Pitfalls to Avoid
Collapsing the two obligations: Care and diligence is about what was checked; independent judgment is about whose judgment the decision represents.
Asking whether a tool was used: The question that helps is which parts are analysis by a person who can be asked about them.
Deciding on the summary: Where an item turns on a number, a term, a legal position or a forecast, read the source.
Reading fluency as certainty: Settled and contested points read the same, and the hedging a person would have added is often gone.
Minuting only the resolution: A record of what was asked and answered is what evidences judgment.
Letting the paper carry the duty: Sub-section (6) marks the office as personal, and sub-section (3) sits with each director.
Assuming the paper will surface a conflict: Sub-section (4) is engaged whether or not the material mentions the director's interest.
Key Statutory Provisions
Section 166 of the Companies Act, 2013: Duties of directors. Sub-section (1) requires a director to act in accordance with the articles of the company, subject to the provisions of the Act. Sub-section (2) requires a director to act in good faith in order to promote the objects of the company for the benefit of its members as a whole, and in the best interests of the company, its employees, the shareholders, the community and for the protection of environment. Sub-section (3) requires a director to exercise his duties with due and reasonable care, skill and diligence and to exercise independent judgment. Sub-section (4) provides that a director shall not involve in a situation in which he may have a direct or indirect interest that conflicts, or possibly may conflict, with the interest of the company. Sub-section (6) provides that a director shall not assign his office and that any assignment so made shall be void. Sub-section (7) provides for a fine of not less than one lakh rupees, which may extend to five lakh rupees, for contravention of the section. The section says nothing about how board material is prepared, and nothing opened for this note decides how it applies to material prepared with a tool.
Sources and References
Companies Act, 2013, section 166
Disclaimer: This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Readers should consult a qualified legal professional for advice specific to their circumstances.



Comments