How to Rely on a Valuation Produced With an AI Model

The report arrives with a range, a methodology section and a comparables table, and somewhere behind it is a model that did most of the arithmetic. Relying on a valuation produced with an AI model is not a question about the model. It is a question about whose duties the report carries, and those sit on a named person.
Step 1: Establish Whether the Valuation Is a Statutory One
Sub-section (1) of section 247 of the Companies Act, 2013 applies where a valuation is required to be made in respect of any property, stocks, shares or goodwill or any other assets, or net worth, or liabilities, under the provisions of that Act. In that case it is to be valued by a person having such qualifications and experience and registered as a valuer in such manner and on such terms and conditions as may be prescribed, and appointed by the audit committee or in its absence by the Board of Directors.
So the first question is whether the Act requires this valuation at all. A management estimate for an internal purpose and a valuation required under the Act are different documents with different consequences, and they are often commissioned in the same breath.
Step 2: Confirm Who Was Appointed, and by Whom
The provision names the appointing body: the audit committee, or in its absence the Board. Where a firm was engaged by management and a registered valuer later signed the report, the appointment does not match the provision.
Check the appointment record before the report is relied on. This is a documentary question with a documentary answer, and it is far easier to fix before the report is issued than afterwards.
Step 3: Read the Four Duties as Four Separate Tests
Sub-section (2) provides that the valuer appointed under sub-section (1) shall make an impartial, true and fair valuation of any assets which may be required to be valued; exercise due diligence while performing the functions as valuer; make the valuation in accordance with such rules as may be prescribed; and not undertake valuation of any assets in which he has a direct or indirect interest.
Each of those is a test the signatory must satisfy. The duties are imposed on the valuer appointed under sub-section (1), which is a person, so on the face of the provision they do not move to a tool that produced the figures.
Step 4: Ask What the Model Was Fed and What It Was Asked
Due diligence in a model assisted valuation is largely about inputs and assumptions: which comparables were selected and on what basis, which period was used, what growth or discount assumptions were applied, and which of those the model chose rather than the valuer.
An assumption the valuer cannot explain is an assumption the valuer has not adopted. That is the practical content of the duty, and it is the question to put before the report is signed rather than after it is challenged.
Step 5: Make the Report Say Where the Figures Came From
A methodology section that describes a method in the abstract does not record what was actually done. Where a tool was used, the report should say which parts of the work it performed, what data it was given, and what the valuer did with the output.
That is likely to protect the valuer more than it exposes them. A report that is silent about a tool and is later shown to have relied on one is in a weaker position than a report that said so.
Step 6: Test the Impartiality Limb Against the Tool's Provenance
Clause (a) requires an impartial, true and fair valuation. Where the model, the data or the platform comes from a party with a stake in the outcome, impartiality is a question about the valuation and not merely about the valuer's own relationships.
Clause (d) is narrower, and bars a valuation of assets in which the valuer has a direct or indirect interest. The two printings consulted for this note differ on the period over which that interest is measured, so no period is stated here and the current text should be checked before the clause is applied.
Step 7: Keep the Working, Not Just the Report
Retain the inputs as supplied, the assumptions as set, the version of the tool used, the date of the run and the valuer's own adjustments to the output. A valuation is reviewed long after it is signed, and by then the tool has usually changed.
Where the working does not exist, the report is the only evidence of the exercise, which means the report has to carry everything that would otherwise be in the file.
Step 8: Decide What the Recipient Is Being Told
Whoever relies on the valuation, a board, an audit committee, a counterparty or a tribunal, is entitled to know what it rests on. Where the engagement letter or the report is silent about model assistance, decide deliberately whether that silence is appropriate rather than leaving it to the template.
The rules prescribed under clause (c) govern how the valuation is to be made and were not opened for this note, so they should be read alongside this provision before any position is taken on disclosure.
Common Pitfalls to Avoid
Not asking whether the Act requires the valuation: Sub-section (1) applies where a valuation is required under the provisions of the Act, and a management estimate is a different document.
Overlooking the appointing body: The provision names the audit committee, or in its absence the Board.
Treating the four duties as one: Impartiality, due diligence, compliance with the prescribed rules and the absence of interest are separate tests.
Assuming the duties move to the tool: A model produces figures; it cannot be impartial, exercise due diligence or declare an interest.
Accepting an assumption nobody can explain: An assumption the valuer cannot explain is one the valuer has not adopted.
Writing a silent methodology section: A report that is silent about a tool and later shown to have used one is worse placed than one that said so.
Keeping the report and not the working: Inputs, assumptions, the version used and the valuer's adjustments are what a later review needs.
Key Statutory Provisions
Sub-section (1) of section 247 of the Companies Act, 2013: Valuation by registered valuers. Where a valuation is required to be made in respect of any property, stocks, shares or goodwill or any other assets, or net worth, or liabilities, under the provisions of the Act, it shall be valued by a person having such qualifications and experience and registered as a valuer in such manner and on such terms and conditions as may be prescribed, and appointed by the audit committee or in its absence by the Board of Directors. The two printings opened for this note differ on parts of the list of assets and on a further requirement about membership of a recognised organisation, so neither is stated here.
Sub-section (2) of section 247 of the Companies Act, 2013: The valuer appointed under sub-section (1) shall make an impartial, true and fair valuation of any assets which may be required to be valued; exercise due diligence while performing the functions as valuer; make the valuation in accordance with such rules as may be prescribed; and not undertake valuation of any assets in which he has a direct or indirect interest. The two printings opened differ on the period over which that interest is measured, so no period is stated here. The penalty provisions of the section also differ between the two printings and are therefore not set out. The current text should be checked before the section is applied.
Sources and References
Companies Act, 2013, section 247
Disclaimer: This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Readers should consult a qualified legal professional for advice specific to their circumstances.



Comments