top of page

How to Handle AI Use by a Tribunal or an Opponent in an Arbitration

Writer: Kaustav Chowdhury
Kaustav Chowdhury
3 days ago
6 min read

Updated: 1 hour ago

Nobody announces it. A directions order arrives phrased unlike anything else in the reference, or a submission cites material nobody filed. Dealing with AI use by a tribunal or by the other side is not a matter of objecting to technology. It is a matter of holding the reference to the three provisions that already govern how it is run.

Step 1: Settle the Procedure at the First Procedural Hearing

Sub-section (2) of section 19 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 provides that, subject to Part I, the parties are free to agree on the procedure to be followed by the arbitral tribunal in conducting its proceedings. Failing such an agreement, sub-section (3) lets the tribunal conduct the proceedings in the manner it considers appropriate.

That order of priority is the whole opportunity. Anything the parties want settled about the use of such tools, by themselves or by the tribunal, is settled by agreement at the outset or it is left to the tribunal's discretion. Raising it after a draft has been circulated is raising it too late.

Step 2: Ask for a Term, Not a Prohibition

A blanket ban is usually resisted and rarely needed. What is useful is narrower: that the determination of the issues and the reasons rest on the tribunal's own analysis, that any material generated by a tool and relied on is disclosed, and that nothing confidential to the reference is put into a service that retains or reuses it.

Framed that way the term describes outcomes rather than software, which is why it survives the next product cycle and why a tribunal is more likely to accept it.

Step 3: Remember What the Tribunal Is Not Bound By

Sub-section (1) of section 19 provides that the arbitral tribunal shall not be bound by the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 or the Indian Evidence Act, 1872. An objection built on a rule of evidence is therefore not the strong point it would be in a suit.

Sub-section (4) goes further: the tribunal's power to conduct proceedings as it considers appropriate includes the power to determine the admissibility, relevance, materiality and weight of any evidence. The practical consequence is that an objection to machine assisted material is usually an objection about weight and about process, not about admissibility.

Step 4: Use the Communication Requirement, Because It Is the Strongest Lever

Sub-section (3) of section 24 requires that all statements, documents or other information supplied to, or applications made to, the arbitral tribunal by one party shall be communicated to the other party, and that any expert report or evidentiary document on which the tribunal may rely in making its decision shall be communicated to the parties.

That provision does not mention technology and does not need to. Where a tribunal would rely on an evidentiary document or an expert report, the parties are entitled to see it. A request framed in those terms asks for nothing novel and is far harder to refuse than a request framed as an inquiry into the tribunal's working method.

Step 5: Treat Equality of Treatment as the Second Lever

Section 18 provides that the parties shall be treated with equality and that each party shall be given a full opportunity to present his case. Where material has influenced the outcome and one side has not seen it, the complaint is about the opportunity to present a case, which is the language the Act itself uses.

Keep the complaint in that register. An objection expressed as a grievance about tools invites a debate about tools. An objection expressed as a want of opportunity engages a provision.

Step 6: Deal With the Opponent's Material the Same Way

Where a submission from the other side appears to contain generated material, the useful response is specific rather than general: identify the proposition, ask for the source relied on, and ask that it be produced.

A request to produce the source is ordinary and it resolves the question either way. An accusation about how the submission was prepared is neither, and it tends to consume the hearing time that should be spent on the proposition itself.

Step 7: Ask for the Hearing Where the Record Needs One

Sub-section (1) of section 24 leaves it to the tribunal, unless otherwise agreed, to decide whether to hold oral hearings for the presentation of evidence or for oral argument or to proceed on documents and other materials, subject to a proviso that it shall hold hearings at an appropriate stage on a request by a party, unless the parties have agreed that no oral hearing shall be held.

Where an issue of this kind arises in a documents only reference, that proviso is the route to having it ventilated rather than exchanged in correspondence. Sub-section (2) adds that the parties are to be given sufficient advance notice of any hearing and of any meeting of the tribunal for the purposes of inspection.

Step 8: Keep the Record Contemporaneous

Whatever course is taken, the position is preserved by what is written at the time: the procedural order recording what was agreed, the letter raising the point, the request for the source and the response to it, each dated.

A point raised in correspondence and then dropped reads very differently from a point pressed and refused. The difference costs one letter and it is not recoverable afterwards.

Common Pitfalls to Avoid

  • Leaving it to the first draft: Sub-section (2) of section 19 gives the parties their agreement on procedure at the outset, and sub-section (3) gives the tribunal the discretion if they do not use it.

  • Asking for a prohibition: A term about disclosure of material relied on and about confidentiality is easier to obtain and does more work.

  • Arguing admissibility: Sub-section (4) of section 19 puts admissibility, relevance, materiality and weight in the tribunal's hands.

  • Framing it as a complaint about tools: Sub-section (3) of section 24 and section 18 are about communication of material and about the opportunity to present a case.

  • Accusing rather than asking: Identify the proposition and ask for the source relied on.

  • Letting it rest in correspondence: Where the reference is on documents only, the proviso to sub-section (1) of section 24 is the route to a hearing.

Key Statutory Provisions

  • Section 18 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996: Equal treatment of parties. The parties shall be treated with equality and each party shall be given a full opportunity to present his case.

  • Section 19 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996: Determination of rules of procedure. Sub-section (1) provides that the arbitral tribunal shall not be bound by the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 or the Indian Evidence Act, 1872. Sub-section (2) provides that, subject to Part I, the parties are free to agree on the procedure to be followed by the tribunal in conducting its proceedings. Sub-section (3) provides that, failing such agreement, the tribunal may, subject to Part I, conduct the proceedings in the manner it considers appropriate. Sub-section (4) provides that this power includes the power to determine the admissibility, relevance, materiality and weight of any evidence.

  • Section 24 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996: Hearings and written proceedings. Sub-section (1) leaves it to the tribunal, unless otherwise agreed by the parties, to decide whether to hold oral hearings for the presentation of evidence or for oral argument or whether to conduct the proceedings on the basis of documents and other materials, with a proviso that it shall hold hearings at an appropriate stage of the proceedings on a request by a party unless the parties have agreed that no oral hearing shall be held, and a further proviso requiring hearings as far as possible on a day to day basis, no adjournment without sufficient cause and permitting costs including exemplary costs on a party seeking an adjournment without sufficient cause. Sub-section (2) requires sufficient advance notice of any hearing and of any meeting of the tribunal for the purposes of inspection of documents, goods or other property. Sub-section (3) requires that all statements, documents or other information supplied to, or applications made to, the tribunal by one party be communicated to the other party, and that any expert report or evidentiary document on which the tribunal may rely in making its decision be communicated to the parties.

Sources and References


Disclaimer: This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Readers should consult a qualified legal professional for advice specific to their circumstances.

Comments


bottom of page