top of page

How to Lead Expert Evidence About an AI System

Writer: Kaustav Chowdhury
Kaustav Chowdhury
6 hours ago
5 min read

A case turns on what a system did, and nobody in the courtroom has seen inside it. Leading expert evidence about an AI system is not a matter of finding an impressive witness. It is a matter of identifying the point on which the court has to form an opinion, and then showing that the witness is specially skilled in it.

Step 1: Identify the Point, Not the Subject

Sub-section (1) of section 39 of the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023 makes relevant the opinions of persons specially skilled upon a point on which the Court has to form an opinion: a point of foreign law or of science or art, or any other field, or as to identity of handwriting or finger impressions. Such persons are called experts.

So the first task is to state the point in one sentence. Not what the system is, but what the court has to decide about it: whether a given input would produce a given output, whether a log reflects what the system did, whether a described behaviour is capable of occurring at all.

Step 2: Use the Words Or Any Other Field

The provision does not confine the skill to science or art. It extends to any other field, and both printings opened for this note carry those words.

That matters because an argument about whether work on a model is a science or an art is an argument nobody needs to have. The question the provision asks is whether the witness is specially skilled in the field the point belongs to.

Step 3: Prove the Skill Before the Opinion

Specially skilled is the statutory qualification and it is proved by material, not asserted in a heading. What the witness has built, examined or tested, over what period, with what training and what independent verification of competence, belongs in the evidence before the opinion does.

A witness whose skill rests on employment by a vendor of the system in question is proving something, and it may not be what the party wants proved. Decide early whether the better witness is the one with the deepest knowledge or the one whose knowledge the court can weigh without discounting it.

Step 4: Know the Separate Route in Sub-Section (2)

Sub-section (2) provides that where in a proceeding the court has to form an opinion on any matter relating to any information transmitted or stored in any computer resource or any other electronic or digital form, the opinion of the Examiner of Electronic Evidence referred to in section 79A of the Information Technology Act, 2000 is a relevant fact. The Explanation provides that such an Examiner shall be an expert.

That is a distinct and narrower route and it is worth identifying at the outset which one the case needs. Section 79A itself was not opened for this note, so nothing is said here about how an Examiner comes to be one.

Step 5: Write the Opinion So the Reasoning Is Visible

An opinion that states a conclusion gives a court nothing to weigh. The report should set out what material the witness examined, what was done to it, what was observed and what follows, in that order, so that each step can be tested separately.

Where the witness could not examine something, say so and say why. An opinion that silently rests on material the witness never saw is the opinion that comes apart under the first question about it.

Step 6: Deal With the Limits of the Examination

Much of what an expert would want is often unavailable: the model itself, the data it was trained on, the version in use at the material time. State plainly what was available, what was not, and what the absence means for the opinion.

A carefully limited opinion is more useful than a confident one, because a court can act on a limit it has been told about and cannot act on one it discovers later.

Step 7: Keep the Opinion Inside the Point

The provision makes relevant the opinion upon the point on which the court has to form an opinion. An expert who proceeds to say what the outcome of the case should be is outside that, and the excess tends to colour how the rest is read.

Mark up the draft report against the point identified in step one and remove anything that does not go to it. That exercise usually shortens the report and strengthens it.

Step 8: Prepare for the Comparison Question

One of the illustrations to sub-section (1) concerns the comparison of a document in question with one proved or admitted to be genuine, and the opinion of experts on whether both were written by the same person.

The structure is worth borrowing. Where a party can put a known specimen of a system's behaviour beside the disputed one, the opinion becomes a comparison rather than an assertion, and a comparison is a familiar form of expert evidence for a court to weigh.

Common Pitfalls to Avoid

  • Leading with the subject: The provision is about the point on which the Court has to form an opinion, which should be stated in one sentence.

  • Arguing science or art: Sub-section (1) extends to any other field, so the argument is unnecessary.

  • Asserting skill instead of proving it: Specially skilled is the statutory qualification and it is proved by material.

  • Missing the separate route: Sub-section (2) and the Explanation deal with the opinion of the Examiner of Electronic Evidence.

  • Stating a conclusion: Material examined, what was done, what was observed and what follows, in that order.

  • Hiding the limits: A court can act on a limit it is told about and not on one it discovers.

  • Straying past the point: An opinion on the outcome of the case is outside the provision and colours the rest.

Key Statutory Provisions

  • Sub-section (1) of section 39 of the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023: Opinions of experts. When the Court has to form an opinion upon a point of foreign law or of science or art, or any other field, or as to identity of handwriting or finger impressions, the opinions upon that point of persons specially skilled in such foreign law, science or art, or any other field, or in questions as to identity of handwriting or finger impressions, are relevant facts and such persons are called experts. Illustrations to the sub-section include the comparison of a document in question with one proved or admitted to have been written by a particular person.

  • Sub-section (2) of section 39 and the Explanation: When in a proceeding the court has to form an opinion on any matter relating to any information transmitted or stored in any computer resource or any other electronic or digital form, the opinion of the Examiner of Electronic Evidence referred to in section 79A of the Information Technology Act, 2000 is a relevant fact, and the Explanation provides that such an Examiner shall be an expert. Section 79A was not opened for this note and is not described here.

Sources and References


Disclaimer: This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Readers should consult a qualified legal professional for advice specific to their circumstances.

Comments


bottom of page