top of page

How to Test Whether an AI Invention Falls Outside Section 3(k)

Writer: Kaustav Chowdhury
Kaustav Chowdhury
6 hours ago
5 min read

Before novelty, before inventive step, before anything a client wants to talk about, an AI invention filed in India meets a single clause that says what is not an invention at all. Working out whether the application clears it is the first drafting decision, not a question for the examination report.

Step 1: Read the Clause, Because It Has Four Limbs

Clause (k) of section 3 of the Patents Act, 1970, under the heading What are not inventions, reads: a mathematical or business method or a computer programme per se or algorithms.

Four things are named. A mathematical method. A business method. A computer programme per se. And algorithms. The last of those is the limb most often overlooked, and unlike the computer programme limb it carries no qualifying words at all.

Step 2: Work Out Which Limb Is Actually in Issue

These are different objections and they are met differently. An objection that the claim is a mathematical method is about what the claim is directed to. An objection that it is a business method is about the field of application. An objection under the computer programme limb is about the form of the claim.

Ask which limb a reader would reach for first on the claim as drafted. Where the answer is the algorithms limb, the drafting problem is different from the one most AI applications are prepared for.

The distinction matters for how the objection is answered. Clause (k) sits in a section headed What are not inventions, so an objection under it goes to subject matter rather than to novelty or inventive step. An answer that addresses only how the invention differs from what came before does not meet it.

Step 3: Treat the Words Per Se as the Question, Not the Answer

The computer programme limb excludes a computer programme per se. Those two words do work that the clause itself does not explain, and what falls outside them is contested. Nothing in the words settles it.

So an opinion that rests on asserting that the invention is more than a programme per se is asserting the conclusion. The useful work is to identify what, on the face of the claim, is said to take it beyond a programme, and to put that in the specification rather than in the argument.

Step 4: Describe the Problem in the Machine, Not in the Output

Where an application is drafted around what the system achieves for a user, the claim reads as a method of doing something with a computer. Where it is drafted around a difficulty in making the system work and how that difficulty was overcome, it reads differently.

This is a specification decision taken at the drafting stage. It cannot be supplied later by argument, because the specification is what the argument has to work from.

Step 5: Check the Claim Against the Business Method Limb Separately

An AI application in a commercial field is likely to attract the business method objection even where the technical content is substantial, because the limb looks at what the claim is for. Insurance pricing, credit decisions, advertising placement and trading all invite it.

Where the invention genuinely lies in how something is computed rather than in what commercial outcome is produced, the claim should say so in those terms. Where it does not genuinely lie there, that is worth knowing before the fee is spent.

Step 6: Keep the Neighbouring Exclusion in View

Clause (m) of the same section excludes a mere scheme or rule or method of performing mental act or method of playing game. An application that describes a sequence of steps a person could in principle carry out invites that clause as well as clause (k).

The two are often argued together, so a specification that answers only the clause (k) objection can find the other one waiting behind it.

Step 7: Decide Whether a Patent Is the Right Instrument at All

A clause that excludes mathematical methods, business methods, programmes per se and algorithms leaves a narrower route than is often assumed. For some inventions the honest advice is that the protection lies elsewhere, or in keeping the method confidential.

Saying that at the outset costs one conversation. Discovering it after prosecution has begun costs considerably more, and the client will reasonably ask why the clause was not read first.

Step 8: Record the Analysis Before Filing

Write down, before the application is filed, which limb was considered the live risk, what in the specification is said to answer it, and what was deliberately left out. A short note is enough.

That note is what whoever handles the examination report will work from, and it is the only record of why the specification was drafted as it was.

Common Pitfalls to Avoid

  • Reading the clause as one objection: It names a mathematical method, a business method, a computer programme per se and algorithms.

  • Overlooking the algorithms limb: It carries no qualifying words, unlike the computer programme limb.

  • Asserting that the invention is more than a programme per se: What falls outside those words is contested and is not settled by the words.

  • Drafting around the user outcome: A specification built on what the system achieves for a user reads as a method of doing something with a computer.

  • Forgetting the business method limb: It looks at what the claim is for, whatever the technical content.

  • Answering only clause (k): Clause (m) excludes a mere scheme or rule or method of performing mental act or method of playing game.

  • Leaving the analysis unrecorded: The note is what whoever answers the examination report has to work from.

Key Statutory Provisions

  • Clause (k) of section 3 of the Patents Act, 1970: Under the heading What are not inventions, the clause reads: a mathematical or business method or a computer programme per se or algorithms. The words per se are not explained in the clause, and what falls outside them is not settled by the words alone. No case on the clause was opened for this note, so none is cited and no test is attributed to any court.

  • Clause (m) of section 3 of the Patents Act, 1970: A mere scheme or rule or method of performing mental act or method of playing game. Both printings opened for this note carry it in the same terms. The other clauses of the section were not opened and are not set out here.

Sources and References


Disclaimer: This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Readers should consult a qualified legal professional for advice specific to their circumstances.

Comments


bottom of page